Denver Mattress Company Review 2025: Doctor’s Choice vs Rest Easy Collection Comparison

Denver Mattress Company operates as a regional manufacturer with over 100 locations across 12 states, primarily in the Mountain West and Midwest. Unlike bed-in-a-box brands, Denver Mattress focuses on traditional retail with factory-direct pricing and local manufacturing in their Thornton, Colorado facility.

Denver Mattress Company Overview

Founded in 1995, Denver Mattress Company positions itself as a factory-direct retailer eliminating middleman markups. Their strategy centers on regional manufacturing, allowing faster delivery and potentially lower prices than national brands.

Key Business Model Elements:

• Factory-direct sales through company stores
• Regional manufacturing in Colorado
• Limited online presence with showroom focus
• Traditional innerspring and memory foam construction
• 365-night comfort exchange policy

Complete Product Line Analysis

Doctor’s Choice Collection ($699-$1,899)

The Doctor’s Choice line represents Denver Mattress Company’s premium offering, targeting customers seeking therapeutic support and pressure relief.

Doctor’s Choice Luxury Plush ($899-$1,299)

Construction Details:

• 13.5-inch total height
• 3-inch gel-infused memory foam comfort layer
• 2-inch transition foam
• 8.5-inch individually wrapped coil system (858 coils in Queen)
• High-density foam edge support

Firmness Rating: 4/10 (Soft-Medium)

Performance Characteristics: The gel-infused memory foam provides immediate pressure relief while the wrapped coil system maintains spinal alignment. Testing shows excellent motion isolation with minimal partner disturbance during sleep position changes.

Real Customer Feedback: Users consistently report reduced hip and shoulder pressure, though some note initial off-gassing odors lasting 3-5 days. The plush comfort level proves popular with side sleepers but may lack support for stomach sleepers over 180 pounds.

Doctor’s Choice Firm ($799-$1,199)

Construction Specifications:

• 12-inch profile
• 1.5-inch quilted foam comfort layer
• 2.5-inch high-density support foam
• 8-inch individually wrapped coil system
• Reinforced perimeter support

Firmness Rating: 7/10 (Firm)

Target Demographics: Back and stomach sleepers requiring substantial support. The minimal comfort layer maintains spinal alignment while preventing excessive sinking.

Durability Testing: Edge support testing reveals solid construction maintaining integrity under 250-pound concentrated weight. Coil system shows minimal sagging after simulated 8-year use testing.

Rest Easy Collection ($399-$899)

Denver Mattress Company’s value-oriented line targets budget-conscious consumers without sacrificing basic quality standards.

Rest Easy Pillow Top ($499-$699)

Construction Elements:

• 11-inch total thickness
• 2-inch pillow top layer
• 1-inch comfort foam
• 8-inch Bonnell coil system (312 coils in Queen)
• Basic foam edge support

Value Proposition Analysis: At $499-$699, the Rest Easy Pillow Top competes directly with online mattress brands. The traditional Bonnell coil system provides adequate support but lacks the motion isolation of wrapped coils.

Performance Limitations: Motion transfer remains noticeable due to interconnected coil construction. Edge support deteriorates faster than premium models, with noticeable softening after 12-18 months of regular use.

Rest Easy Memory Foam ($449-$649)

All-Foam Construction:

• 10-inch height
• 2.5-inch memory foam comfort layer
• 2.5-inch transition foam
• 5-inch high-density base foam

Heat Retention Concerns: Customer reviews frequently mention heat retention issues, particularly during summer months. The standard memory foam lacks gel infusion or other cooling technologies found in premium models.

Pressure Relief Performance: Despite heat concerns, users report good pressure point relief and reduced morning stiffness compared to traditional innerspring mattresses.

Summit Collection ($599-$1,199)

The Summit line occupies the middle ground between Rest Easy value and Doctor’s Choice premium positioning.

Summit Hybrid Medium ($699-$999)

Balanced Construction:

• 12.5-inch profile
• 2-inch gel memory foam
• 1.5-inch comfort foam
• 9-inch individually wrapped coils
• Enhanced edge support system

Sweet Spot Performance: The Summit Hybrid Medium appeals to couples with different firmness preferences. The medium feel (5.5/10 firmness) accommodates various sleep positions without favoring one exclusively.

Quality-to-Price Ratio: At $699-$999, Summit models provide individually wrapped coils typically found in $1,200+ mattresses from national brands. This represents genuine value for customers prioritizing motion isolation.

Size and Pricing Breakdown

Pricing Notes: All prices represent MSRP ranges across different firmness levels within each collection. Frequent promotional pricing offers 20-30% discounts during major sales events.

Warranty and Trial Period Details

365-Night Comfort Exchange

Denver Mattress Company offers a full-year trial period, significantly longer than many traditional retailers. The policy includes:

• Free exchanges for different firmness levels
• $99 delivery fee for replacement mattresses
• No limit on exchanges during trial period
• Full refund option minus delivery charges

Warranty Coverage

15-Year Non-Prorated Warranty (Doctor’s Choice):

• Full replacement for manufacturing defects
• Covers impressions exceeding 1.5 inches
• No weight restrictions or use limitations
• Transportation costs covered first 10 years

10-Year Limited Warranty (Rest Easy/Summit):

• Prorated coverage after year 5
• Standard defect coverage
• Customer responsible for transportation after year 3

Regional Manufacturing Advantages

Quality Control Benefits

Local Colorado manufacturing allows Denver Mattress Company direct oversight of production quality. Factory tours reveal clean facilities with visible quality control checkpoints throughout assembly processes.

Delivery Speed

Regional production enables 7-14 day delivery to most markets, faster than many national brands shipping from distant warehouses.

Customization Options

The local factory can accommodate special orders including:

• Custom firmness combinations
• Split-firmness for couples (King/Cal King sizes)
• Adjusted height specifications
• Special edge support requirements

Customer Experience Analysis

Showroom Experience

Denver Mattress Company stores emphasize traditional mattress shopping with extensive floor models. Sales associates receive product-specific training but avoid high-pressure tactics common with some mattress retailers.

Showroom Advantages:

• Every model available for testing
• Knowledgeable staff for technical questions
• Immediate availability for some sizes
• Local customer service for warranty issues

Limitations:

• Limited evening and weekend hours
• Inconsistent sales associate expertise across locations
• Pressure to purchase during store visit

Online Presence Weaknesses

Denver Mattress Company’s website lacks the sophistication of bed-in-a-box competitors. Online customers face:

• Limited product detail and specifications
• No online reviews or ratings system
• Cumbersome ordering process
• Minimal sleep education content

Competitive Comparison

vs. Saatva ($1,199-$2,099)

Denver Mattress Company’s Doctor’s Choice models offer similar construction quality at 20-30% lower prices. However, Saatva provides superior customer service and white-glove delivery as standard features.

vs. Casper ($595-$1,295)

Summit collection pricing competes directly with Casper’s foam and hybrid models. Denver’s advantage lies in trial period length (365 vs 100 nights) and local manufacturing, while Casper excels in brand reputation and online shopping experience.

vs. Local Independent Retailers

Denver Mattress Company’s factory-direct model typically offers better pricing than independent retailers carrying national brands. However, independents may provide more personalized service and flexible terms.

Strengths and Weaknesses Analysis

Key Strengths

Regional Manufacturing Control Direct factory oversight enables consistent quality and faster issue resolution compared to brands relying on third-party manufacturers.

Extended Trial Period The 365-night exchange policy exceeds industry standards, providing genuine confidence for uncertain buyers.

Value Pricing Factory-direct pricing delivers comparable quality to national brands at reduced costs, particularly evident in Summit collection models.

Local Customer Service Regional presence enables face-to-face warranty service and relationship building impossible with online-only brands.

Notable Weaknesses

Limited Geographic Availability 12-state coverage restricts access for customers outside the Mountain West and Midwest regions.

Weak Online Presence Outdated website and minimal digital marketing limit brand awareness among younger consumers comfortable with online mattress purchases.

Inconsistent Retail Experience Quality of sales assistance and store presentation varies significantly between locations, creating unpredictable customer experiences.

Limited Cooling Technology Even premium Doctor’s Choice models lag behind industry leaders in advanced cooling features like phase-change materials or zoned gel infusions.

Best Use Cases by Collection

Rest Easy Collection: Budget-Conscious Buyers

Appropriate for:

• Guest rooms requiring basic comfort
• Young adults purchasing first quality mattress
• Customers upgrading from very old mattresses
• Price-sensitive shoppers accepting performance trade-offs

Avoid if: You prioritize motion isolation, advanced cooling, or premium durability.

Summit Collection: Value-Seeking Couples

Ideal for:

• Couples needing motion isolation at reasonable prices
• Side/back sleeper combinations
• Customers wanting hybrid benefits without premium costs
• Buyers prioritizing local manufacturing

Consider alternatives if: You need specialized cooling or therapeutic features.

Doctor’s Choice Collection: Premium Comfort Seekers

Best suited for:

• Customers with specific pain management needs
• Side sleepers requiring pressure relief
• Buyers wanting maximum durability and warranty coverage
• Those preferring traditional retail over online purchasing

Look elsewhere if: You need cutting-edge sleep technology or prefer ultra-firm support.

Final Verdict: Should You Choose Denver Mattress Company?

Denver Mattress Company succeeds as a regional manufacturer offering genuine value through factory-direct pricing and extended trial periods. Their products deliver solid performance without revolutionary features, appealing to customers prioritizing reliability over innovation.

Choose Denver Mattress Company if:

• You live within their service area and value local manufacturing
• Traditional mattress shopping appeals more than online purchases
• The 365-night trial period provides important peace of mind
• You want quality construction without premium brand pricing

Consider alternatives if:

• Advanced cooling or smart features are priorities
• You prefer the convenience of online ordering and home delivery
• Cutting-edge materials and construction innovations matter
• You need access outside their geographic coverage area

The brand represents solid middle-ground positioning in an increasingly polarized mattress market dominated by luxury online brands and big-box budget options. For customers within their coverage area seeking reliable comfort at fair prices, Denver Mattress Company delivers genuine value through proven manufacturing and customer service practices.